Netflix's Big Viewership Numbers Mean Very Little

When it comes to evaluating if a movie is a hit or a miss, at least commercially, there’s a very easy metric for that: box office numbers. Movies need to make money; to make money, they need to sell tickets at theaters. Ticket prices can vary depending on where you live, the time of day, regular or plush reclining seats, and so on, yet they’re a pretty standard—and reliable—way of figuring out whether a film release is actually successful. Television is a little trickier; Nielsen ratings, the standard for TV, are statistics based on a sample size of households that provide Nielsen Media Research with their viewing habits. The figures aren’t as precise, but they work—at least for the advertisers looking to buy airtime based on the viewership of popular shows.

Related Stories

Digital CultureNetflix's The Circle Is the Best TV Show About the Internet

Fan-Tastic Planet

Netflix's Carla Engelbrecht Chooses Her Own Adventures

The Monitor

The Witcher Will Get a Second Season on NetflixHow does it work, then, for a streaming service? Well, as Netflix revealed this week, the answer is however the companies want to! Following the launch of the original series The Witcher, as well as the premiere of the Michael Bay-directed, Ryan Gosling-starring action flick 6 Underground, the streamer issued a fourth-quarter earnings report this week boasting to shareholders that the Henry Cavill-starring fantasy series was “our biggest season one TV series ever” (emphasis Netflix’s). According to the streaming firm, that meant 76 million households watched the show in its first four weeks. 6 Underground, meanwhile, was viewed by 83 million in the same amount of time.
But pull out your salt mill and prepare your asterisks for those huge numbers. Netflix—which only selectively releases viewing numbers for its most popular shows and films—has an ever-evolving definition of what a “view” really means. Previously, when the company announced its 2018 original film Bird Box had brought in 80 million viewers in the four weeks after its premiere, the caveat was that the number reflected users who watched at least 70 percent of the film. For this new crop of viewership data—which notably doesn't include bragging rights for The Irishman, Marriage Story, or The Two Popes, the three Netflix films up for Academy Awards next month—the metric is very different. As The Hollywood Reporter notes, “Now, it will count anyone who ‘chose to watch and did watch at least 2 minutes’ of a title as a viewer. ... Per Netflix, it is ‘long enough to indicate the choice was intentional’ but more accurately shows popularity than the 70 percent threshold, which may have negatively impacted longer projects.”
Two minutes? Two minutes!!! That is a bizarrely low threshold for entry into, say, a 10-part fantasy drama featuring a character that could best be described as “Legolas with an Equinox membership” with episodes that run between 47 and 67 minutes. Can one even get past the opening credit sequence? The trailer for The Witcher runs two minutes and 20 seconds. Meanwhile, two minutes of The Irishman , which runs three and a half hours, amounts to 0.95 percent of the total film. You’d barely get through the opening tracking shot at the assisted living facility where an aging Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro) is primed to reflect back on his long life of crime. I like to imagine me, an occasional movie critic, turning off a film after two minutes and writing a review. I mean, according to Netflix’s data, I’ve seen it. Two minutes is enough!
(OK, this is where I include a possibly deranged parenthetical aside to say, once again: Two minutes??? Is that possibly a reasonable amount of time to consume or engage with anything? Imagine enjoying anything that lasts two minutes [winky-face-emoji]. It is absurd! It's a reminder that Netflix is, at heart, a technology company, and can just say whatever it wants and most people will reply “Mmm yes, of course, you’re right, let’s disrupt our collective concept of metrics and statistics and data valuation forever.” Yes, the internet is crushing our attention spans, but 6 Underground isn’t a TikTok—or even a YouTube video, for that matter. Perhaps expecting every viewer to finish what they're watching is asking a lot, but maybe count their view after 10 minutes, or 15? Imagine putting in two minutes of work and saying, “Well, the intention was there, so I don’t see why it doesn’t count?” If this paragraph even makes it into this esteemed publication, it might just be because my editor has already shrugged, released a giant sigh, and said “Eh, I’ve been staring at this for two minutes, I’m sure the rest is fine, whatever. Hit Publish!”) [Editor's note: I read it, even this paragraph. Gave it two minutes of rock-solid edits. Circle , send message.]